Is a Home Warranty Service Worth It for Homeowners?
Home warranty services work through a service contract that pays for the repair or replacement of covered home systems and appliances when they break down from normal wear and tear. You pay a yearly or monthly premium, plus a service call fee each time a technician visits. Plans differ widely in what they cover, how much they pay per repair and how claims work, so comparing several quotes side by side is the most reliable way to find coverage that fits your home and budget.
The unfortunate reality of homeownership is that it can be expensive to properly maintain a roof and residence. Even with adequate maintenance, major home appliances and systems are susceptible to breaking down due to normal wear and tear. A plan can help manage that risk, but weigh the monthly or annual premiums plus service fees for technician visits before purchasing one.
The risk and reward of buying a plan make choosing the right one important. American Home Quotes helps homeowners compare home warranty plans from multiple providers, with free quotes and no obligation. Before purchasing, review what is covered, the total premium cost and the service fees so you can make the best decision for your home and your finances.
Table of Contents
What Types of Repairs Are Typically Covered by a Home Warranty?
Home warranties typically cover major home systems and appliances, including HVAC systems, but the specific items and scope vary by plan. Coverage can vary significantly between providers and plan levels, so it’s essential to review the specific terms and exclusions before purchasing. Many companies offer basic plans that cover essential systems, with optional add-ons for additional appliances or specialized equipment.
Here’s what’s commonly included:
- Major Home Systems: HVAC systems, interior plumbing and interior electrical systems.
- Kitchen and Laundry Appliances: Refrigerators, ranges and ovens, dishwashers, built-in microwaves, garbage disposals, and washer and dryer units.
- Water-Related Systems: Water heaters, sump pumps and well pumps are commonly covered items, either in the base plan or as add-ons.
- Important Coverage Limitations: Most home warranties only cover normal wear and tear, which is the expected deterioration that happens over time with everyday usage. Damages from other causes, such as natural disasters, accidental breakage, or lack of maintenance, usually aren’t covered.
With so many coverage options and plans, comparing quotes from multiple providers helps you identify the most cost-effective warranty for their home.
How Do Systems, Appliance and Combo Home Warranty Plans Compare?
Most providers sell coverage in a few common plan types. The table below shows what each type usually includes, what it usually leaves out and the questions worth asking before you buy.
| Plan type | What it typically covers | Common exclusions | Often a fit for | Questions to ask |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Systems plan | HVAC, interior plumbing, interior electrical and the water heater | Appliances, problems that existed before coverage started, damage from poor maintenance | Homes with aging heating, cooling or plumbing systems | What is the repair limit for the HVAC system? Is ductwork included? |
| Appliance plan | Refrigerator, range or oven, dishwasher, built-in microwave, washer and dryer | Home systems, cosmetic damage, items not listed in the contract | Homes with newer systems but older appliances | Is the refrigerator ice maker included? Are the washer and dryer standard or add-ons? |
| Combo plan | Both major systems and appliances in one contract | Listed exclusions, code upgrades, problems that existed before coverage started | Homeowners who want one plan for most breakdowns | What are the per-item and yearly caps? How is the service fee charged on each claim? |
| Add-on coverage | Optional items such as pools, spas, septic systems, well pumps or a second refrigerator | Anything not added to the contract | Homes with equipment a standard plan leaves out | What does each add-on cost per year? Does it share a cap with the base plan? |
Coverage limits, service fees and exclusions vary by provider and by state, so confirm the details in each contract before you buy.
How Does a Home Warranty Differ From Homeowners Insurance?
While similar, home warranties and insurance are two distinct types of financial protection for homeowners that serve different purposes and cover different types of problems, though they can complement each other. Homeowners’ insurance covers events that might happen, like theft, fire, storm damage, and flooding. Home warranty plans cover items that might inevitably stop working properly, like heating and AC, electrical, plumbing, and kitchen and laundry appliances.
The main difference between a home warranty and home insurance is that a homeowners policy provides more extensive coverage to help cover the entire property, including belongings and personal injury, while a warranty will only apply to certain appliances or systems. Having a home warranty is optional, but homeowners insurance is typically required by mortgage and home equity lenders, especially in disaster-prone states like California and Florida.
Another difference is that insurance plans for residences generally have deductibles that must be paid before the insurance company begins paying for the loss. With a home warranty, the provider typically pays for covered repairs or replacements up to the limits in the contract, and you pay a service call fee for each claim.
What Are the Pros and Cons of Purchasing a Home Warranty?
The pros and cons of purchasing a home warranty will vary based on the needs of the homeowner. For older homes or those with outdated appliances or systems nearing the end of their lifespan, the positives of purchasing a home warranty can definitely outweigh the negatives. With many aspects to consider, here are the key pros and cons of purchasing a home warranty:
Pros
- Financial Protection: A warranty could help homeowners cover at least some of the cost of repairing expensive appliances and systems that break down when funds are limited.
- Peace of Mind: Home warranties provide predictable costs and reduce stress about unexpected breakdowns, especially for older homes or aging appliances.
- Convenience: When covered items break, you can typically just call the warranty company, which will arrange for a technician to come out.
Cons
- Cost Can Add Up: A monthly home warranty plan plus service fees can add up if a claim is never filed.
- Limited Control: Not being able to pick a specific technician for repair work is a common frustration, as the warranty company chooses the repair contractors.
- Coverage Limitations: Home warranty companies often impose dollar limits per repair, per item, or per year. These restrictions can vary greatly by provider. Exclusions and caps may limit benefits, and items listed as excluded from coverage include repairs needed due to improper maintenance or natural disasters.
- Quality Issues: Some home warranties may have a limited number of covered repairs and limited service availability.
- No Guarantee of Savings: If nothing goes wrong, you could pay premiums and service fees without ever using the warranty.
Despite the potential positives and negatives, the decision ultimately depends on the home’s age, the homeowner’s risk tolerance, available emergency funds, and comfort level with the coverage limitations.
What Should You Look for When Choosing a Home Warranty Company?
When choosing a home warranty company, here are the key factors to evaluate:
- Coverage and Contract Details: When reviewing a home warranty contract, look for coverage details, such as included systems and appliances, service fees, limits on repair and replacement costs, claim processes, and any exclusions for preexisting conditions or specific items.
- Customer Service and Reputation: Ask whether the company is registered to sell home warranties in your state, where your state requires it, and read recent customer reviews and complaint history. Also consider whether a provider allows customers to file claims online or choose their contractor, and how extensive their customer service hours are.
- Contractor Selection Options: Plans that let you choose your own technician can give you more confidence that the repairs will be done right.
- Pricing Structure: Compare plans on coverage, rates, service fees and customer service, not on the premium alone.
- Research and Reputation: Researching several home warranty companies lets you evaluate reputation, coverage options and pricing structures side by side.
Home Warranty FAQs
How do I get a home warranty quote online?
Share basic details about your home, such as its size, its age and the systems and appliances you want covered. Then compare the coverage, caps and service fees in each quote, not just the price. You can also call 1-877-820-1636 to start comparing quotes.
How much does a home warranty cost?
Cost depends on the plan type, the size and age of the home, any add-ons you choose and the service call fee charged on each claim. Comparing quotes for the same level of coverage shows the real difference between providers.
Can I choose my own repair technician?
Most providers assign a technician from their own network. Some plans let you use your own contractor or offer reimbursement instead, so ask about this before you buy.
Is there a waiting period before coverage starts?
Many plans include a waiting period after purchase before you can file a claim. Check the contract for the exact length and for any exceptions.
Does a home warranty cover problems that already exist?
Usually not. Most contracts exclude problems that existed before coverage began, so a system that is already failing may not qualify for repair or replacement.
Is American Home Quotes a home warranty company?
No. American Home Quotes does not sell or issue home warranty plans and does not handle claims. It helps homeowners compare plans from independent providers. For service or a claim on an existing plan, contact your warranty provider directly.
Start Comparing Quotes for Home Warranty Plans Today
To identify the right home warranty services for your needs, it is vital to understand the risks and rewards that come with each plan and provider. Choosing a plan tailored to your specific needs can significantly impact your overall satisfaction. American Home Quotes offers a platform that helps homeowners compare home warranty plans from multiple providers, with free quotes and no obligation. Before making a purchase, review the coverage details, total premium costs and any service fees involved, so you can make an informed decision that protects your home and your finances. Contact American Home Quotes at 1-877-820-1636 to start comparing quotes from home warranty companies today.





